The Ultimate Self-Editing Checklist for Writers

Arun Nair - Author
By Arunn
Refine your writing with our comprehensive Self-Editing Checklist. Discover key steps to polish and perfect your manuscripts before publication.

Share this Article

Self-editing is an important step in the writing process that allows writers to refine their work and catch mistakes before their work is seen by others. This helps help writers identify common mistakes, such as grammatical errors, usage errors, stylistic issues, and formatting errors, that can detract from the effectiveness of their writing.

The article will provide an overview of the most common mistakes that writers make, along with tips and strategies for identifying and correcting these issues.

Common Grammatical Mistakes

Subject-verb agreement

Subject-verb agreement is one of the most common grammatical mistakes that writers make, as it can be tricky to get right in certain situations. When the subject and verb of a sentence do not agree in terms of number and person, the sentence can become awkward or even confusing to readers.

Examples of subject-verb agreement errors:

"The group of students is divided in their opinions." (Incorrect: "is" should be "are" to match the plural subject "students")

"She don't have time to go to the store." (Incorrect: "don't" should be "doesn't" to match the singular subject "she")

To avoid subject-verb agreement errors, it is important to carefully consider the subject and verb of each sentence and ensure that they match in terms of number and person.

Pronoun-antecedent agreement

Pronoun-antecedent agreement is another key aspect of grammar that is important for clear and effective writing. Pronouns are words that replace nouns or noun phrases, such as "he," "she," "it," "they," and "them." The antecedent is the noun or noun phrase that the pronoun refers to.

In order for a sentence to be grammatically correct, the pronoun must agree with its antecedent in terms of number, gender, and person. For example, in the sentence "Tom walked because he needed exercise," the pronoun "he" refers to the antecedent "Tom" and agrees in terms of gender and person.

Unclear pronoun-antecedent agreement occurs when the pronoun and its antecedent are unclear, making it difficult for readers to know to what the pronoun refers. This mistake can happen when there are multiple nouns or noun phrases in a sentence, and the writer has not made it clear which one the pronoun refers to.

Examples of sentences with unclear pronoun-antecedent agreement:

"When Jane saw Susan, she was happy." (Unclear: Does "she" refer to Jane or Susan?)

"When the teachers gave the students their test, they were nervous." (It's unclear if "they" refers to the teachers or the students.)

To avoid unclear pronoun-antecedent agreement, writers should make sure that their pronouns have clear antecedents. Here are some tips to help:

Here are some tips:

Use specific names or nouns when referring to people, places, or things to avoid confusion.

If a pronoun might be unclear, use a noun to refer to the subject again to clarify the antecedent.

Use relative pronouns such as "that," "which," or "who" to clarify which antecedent the pronoun refers to.

Reread your writing and ask yourself if it's clear who or what the pronoun refers to.

Tense consistency

Tense refers to the form of a verb that indicates the time of an action, whether it is in the past, present, or future. Tense consistency means that the verb tense remains the same throughout a sentence or paragraph, so that readers can follow the action of the sentence easily and understand the timeframe of events being described.

Failure to do so can lead to confusion and unclear writing. For example, if a writer switches from the present tense to the past tense in the middle of a paragraph without a clear reason for doing so, the reader may become confused and find it difficult to follow the narrative.

Examples of tense consistency errors:

"She writes a letter and mailed it to him." (Error: "writes" should be "wrote" to maintain past tense consistency.)

"I am going to the store and I bought some bread." (Error: "am going" should be "went" to maintain past tense consistency.)

Sentence structure

A poorly constructed sentence can lead to confusion, ambiguity, and even make the message of the sentence unclear.

One common mistake in sentence structure is the run-on sentence, which occurs when two or more complete sentences are combined without proper punctuation or conjunctions. This can make sentences long and difficult to read, as well as make it challenging for readers to understand the meaning of the sentence.

Example of run-on sentence:

The dog barked loudly, the cat ran away.

Correction:

The dog barked loudly, and the cat ran away.

OR

The dog barked loudly; the cat ran away.

OR

The dog barked loudly. The cat ran away.

Another mistake is the sentence fragment, which is an incomplete sentence that is missing a subject, verb, or complete thought. This can make writing choppy and difficult to follow, as well as make it hard for the reader to understand the meaning of the sentence.

Example of a Sentence fragment:

Sitting on the couch, watching TV.

Correction:

I was sitting on the couch, watching TV.

Punctuation errors

One common mistake in punctuation is the misuse of commas. Commas are used to separate items in a list, join two independent clauses, set off parenthetical phrases, and clarify sentence structure. Incorrect use of commas can result in confusion and ambiguity, or even change the meaning of a sentence.

Another mistake is the misuse of apostrophes, which are used to show possession or to indicate the omission of letters in a contraction.

Examples of punctuation errors:

Error:

Let’s eat grandma!

It is clear that the missing comma has changed the meaning of the sentence!

The correct sentence is ...

Let’s eat, grandma!

Error:

His toy's are in the basket.

Correction:

His toys are in the basket.

Common Usage Errors

Misused words, Homophones (e.g., affect/effect, accept/except)

Misused words are a common error in writing, as many words have similar spellings or sounds but different meanings.

For example, a common mistake is one confusing “affect and effect”. “Affect” is a verb that means to influence or cause a change, while “effect” is a noun that refers to the result or consequence of an action.

examples of misused words:

Your/You're: "Your" is a possessive pronoun that shows ownership or belonging. "You're" is a contraction of "you are." For example: "Your shoes are untied" and "You're late for the meeting."

There/Their/They're: "There" refers to a place or location. "Their" is a possessive pronoun that shows ownership or belonging. "They're" is a contraction of "they are." For example: "Put the book over there," "Their car is parked in the driveway," and "They're going to the movies tonight."

Then/Than: "Then" is an adverb that refers to a point in time. "Than" is used for comparisons. For example: "I ate breakfast, then I went to work" and "I would rather go for a walk than watch TV."

Who/Whom: "Who" is used as the subject of a sentence, while "whom" is used as the object of a verb or preposition. For example: "Who is going to the party?" and "To whom should I address the letter?"

Compliment/Complement: "Compliment" refers to praise or admiration. "Complement" means to complete or enhance something. For example: "I received a compliment on my outfit" and "The wine complemented the meal perfectly."

Accept/Except: "Accept" means to receive or agree to something. "Except" means excluding or with the exception of. For example: "I will accept the job offer" and "Everyone was there except for John."

Stationary/Stationery: "Stationary" means not moving or fixed in one place. "Stationery" refers to paper, envelopes, and other writing materials. For example: "The car was stationary at the red light" and "I bought some new stationery for my business."

Jargon and slang

While jargon and slang may be appropriate in certain contexts, such as informal writing or technical documents, they should be avoided in most types of writing.

Jargon refers to specialized terminology or language used in a particular field or industry. While jargon can be useful for communicating technical information to others in the same field, it can be confusing or intimidating to those who are unfamiliar with the terminology. In addition, the overuse of jargon can make writing dry and difficult to read.

Slang, on the other hand, refers to informal language that is often used in casual conversation or in certain social groups. Slang can add personality and character to writing, but it can also be inappropriate or offensive in certain contexts. Overuse of slang can make writing appear unprofessional or juvenile.

examples of jargon and slang usage errors:

"The project is behind schedule due to issues with the API integration and the database migration to speed-up concurrency." (Error: overuse of technical jargon that may not be understood by all readers.)

"The new restaurant is totally lit, you should definitely check it out." (Error: use of slang that may not be appropriate in a formal review or article.)

Common Stylistic Errors

Overuse of adjectives and adverbs

Adjectives and adverbs can be useful for adding detail and nuance to writing, but overuse can make the writing feel cluttered and wordy.

Adjectives are words that describe or modify nouns, while adverbs are words that describe or modify verbs, adjectives, or other adverbs. While some adjectives and adverbs can be effective for adding detail and emphasis to writing, too many can create an overwhelming and unnecessary amount of description.

examples of the overuse of adjectives and adverbs:

"The stunning, breathtaking, magnificent sunset slowly faded into the dark, mysterious, tranquil night, as the bright, radiant stars twinkled in the vast, endless, limitless sky." (Error: overuse of adjectives that may be unnecessary for the reader to understand the scene.)

"He quickly, nervously, and apprehensively walked down the dark, eerily, and ominously quiet hallway, cautiously, fearfully, and timidly peering around each corner." (Error: overuse of adverbs that may not add to the tone or impact of the sentence.)

Passive voice

Passive voice occurs when the subject of a sentence is being acted upon rather than performing the action itself. This can result in sentences that are wordy, vague, and difficult to follow.

Passive voice is often used in academic or scientific writing, where the emphasis is on the research or results rather than the person who conducted the research. However, in most other types of writing, active voice is preferred because it is more direct, concise, and engaging.

examples of passive voice:

"The report was written by the new intern." (Passive voice)

"The new intern wrote the report." (Active voice)

Wordiness and redundancy

Wordiness can occur in many forms, such as using unnecessary words or phrases, over-explaining a concept, or using complex sentence structures that are difficult to follow. This can make writing seem bloated and confusing, and can detract from the main message.

Redundancy occurs when a writer repeats the same idea or message using different words or phrases. This can make writing repetitive and dull, and can cause readers to lose interest in the material.

examples of wordiness and redundancy:

"Due to the fact that the company is experiencing a decline in profits, it has become necessary for us to implement certain cost-cutting measures, such as reducing expenses, eliminating redundancies, and consolidating operations."

(Wordy: Here's a less wordy version of the same sentence: Because the company's profits are declining, we need to cut costs by reducing expenses, eliminating redundancies, and consolidating operations.”)

"She nodded her head in agreement."

(Redundant: In this sentence, the phrase "nodded her head" is redundant because nodding already implies movement of the head. A simpler and more concise version of the sentence would be: She nodded in agreement.)

Lack of variety in sentence length and structure

When all the sentences in a piece of writing are of similar length and structure, it can create a repetitive rhythm that detracts from the overall quality of the writing.

To avoid this stylistic error, writers should aim to vary sentence length and structure to create a more interesting and engaging reading experience. This can be done by incorporating short and long sentences, as well as different sentence structures such as simple, compound, complex, and compound-complex sentences.

examples of how to vary sentence length and structure:

Simple sentence: "She went to the store."

Compound sentence: "She went to the store, but she forgot her wallet."

Complex sentence: "After she went to the store, she realized that she had forgotten her wallet."

Compound-complex sentence: "She went to the store, but she forgot her wallet, so she had to go back home and get it before she could buy anything."

By varying sentence length and structure, writers can create a more engaging and dynamic reading experience.

Here are some tips:

Start with a mix of simple, compound, complex, and compound-complex sentences.

E.g. "I woke up early this morning. I made myself a cup of coffee and sat down to check my emails. After I finished my emails, I visited my friend’s house. While we were catching up over pancakes and eggs, she told me about her new job and how excited she was about it.”

Use shorter sentences for emphasis or to convey a sense of urgency or action. E.g. We must hurry up!

Use transition words and phrases to link ideas and create a flow between sentences. E.g. Firstly, we will be talking about the importance of preservation.

Common Formatting Errors

Inconsistent font and spacing

Choose a single font style and size and use it consistently throughout the text.

Use the same line spacing and margin settings throughout the text.

Check formatting carefully when copying and pasting text from other sources, as this can often introduce inconsistent formatting.

Inconsistent use of capitalization

Capitalizing words that should be in lowercase, such as common nouns or prepositions.

Not capitalizing proper nouns, such as names of people, places, or brands.

Capitalizing words for emphasis, which can be confusing and distracting.

Tips for Effective Self-Editing

Take a break between writing and editing

When we've just finished writing a piece, we can be too close to it to edit it effectively. We may overlook errors or have trouble identifying areas that need improvement because we're too familiar with the text.

Taking a break, even for just a few hours, can help us gain some distance from the text and approach it with a fresh perspective when we're ready to edit.

Print out your work and read it aloud

One of the most effective tips for self-editing your writing is to print out your work and read it aloud. This technique can help you identify errors and areas of improvement that may have been overlooked when reading silently on a screen.

Here are some tips:

Print out your work: Printing out your work can help you see your writing in a different format and make it easier to read.

Find a quiet space: Find a quiet space where you can read your work aloud without interruptions. This can help you focus on the content of your writing and identify areas of improvement.

Read slowly: Reading your work aloud slowly can help you catch errors or awkward phrasing that may have been overlooked when reading silently.

Mark up your work, and make notes: As you read your work aloud, mark up any errors, awkward phrasing, or areas that could use improvement such as grammar errors, word choice, or sentence structure.

Listen to your writing: Listening to your writing can help you catch errors and awkward phrasing that you may have missed when reading silently. Consider using text-to-speech software to help you listen to your work.

Read your work multiple times: After making changes based on your initial reading, read your work aloud again to see if there are any other areas that need improvement.

Use a grammar and spell-check tool

These tools can help writers catch basic errors in spelling, grammar, and punctuation that might have otherwise gone unnoticed. While these tools are not foolproof and can sometimes miss errors or suggest incorrect changes, they can still be a valuable tool in the self-editing process.

Here are some tips:

Use a trusted tool: There are many grammar and spell-check tools available online, so it's important to choose a tool that is reputable and widely used. Some popular options include Grammarly, Hemingway, and ProWritingAid.

Use the tool after writing: It's best to use a grammar and spell-check tool after you have finished writing, as this will allow you to focus on the content and structure of your writing before checking for errors.

Review suggested changes carefully: Grammar and spell-check tools can sometimes suggest incorrect changes, so it's important to review the suggested changes carefully before accepting them.

Use multiple tools: No single grammar and spell-check tool is perfect, so it can be useful to use multiple tools to catch as many errors as possible. This can help to ensure that you catch a wide range of errors and can make more effective edits.

Use the tool as a guide: Grammar and spell-check tools can be a useful guide in the self-editing process, but they should not be relied on as the sole method of editing. It's important to read through your writing carefully and use your own judgment to make sure that your writing is clear, concise, and effective.

Get feedback from others

Getting feedback from others is a key tip for effective self-editing, as it allows writers to gain an outside perspective on their writing and identify areas that need improvement.

Feedback from others can come from a variety of sources, including peers, mentors, or professional editors.

Here are some tips:

Find a trusted reviewer: Look for someone who is knowledgeable about writing and who can provide constructive criticism in a supportive manner.

Be specific about what you want feedback on: Provide clear instructions about the type of feedback you are looking for. For example, if you are working on a research paper, you may want feedback on the organization of your ideas, the clarity of your writing, or the accuracy of your data.

Consider different perspectives: Seek feedback from a variety of sources to get a well-rounded understanding of your writing. Consider asking someone who is not familiar with your topic to see if your writing is accessible to a general audience.

Be open to feedback: Be prepared to receive constructive criticism and use it to improve your writing. Remember that feedback is not a personal attack, but rather an opportunity for growth and improvement.

Revise and refine: Use the feedback you receive to revise and refine your writing. Consider multiple revisions until you are satisfied with the final product.

Use a style guide

A style guide is a set of guidelines that provides writers with the rules and conventions of writing for a particular language, field, or organization.

Choose a style guide that is appropriate for your field or organization. For example, the Associated Press (AP) style guide is commonly used in journalism, while the Modern Language Association (MLA) style guide is used in academic writing.

Keep a copy of the style guide on hand for future reference. This can be a physical copy or a digital version, depending on your preference.

Check for accuracy

Writing that is inaccurate can confuse or mislead readers, and can detract from the overall effectiveness of the text.

Here are some tips:

Fact-check: If you've included factual information in your writing, make sure that it is accurate. Verify information through reputable sources, and double-check that you've correctly cited your sources.

Check for consistency: If you've used acronyms, abbreviations, or technical terms in your writing, make sure you've used them consistently throughout the text. This can help avoid confusion or ambiguity.

Review numbers and data: If you've included numbers or data in your writing, make sure they are accurate and presented in a clear and meaningful way. Check your calculations, and make sure your data is from reliable sources.

Get feedback: Ask someone else to review your writing for accuracy. A fresh set of eyes can often spot errors or inconsistencies that you may have missed.

Consider your audience

When editing your writing, it's important to keep in mind who your audience is, what they expect from your writing, and how you can best communicate your message to them.

Here are some tips:

Define your audience: Consider who your audience is and what they are looking for in your writing. Are they experts in the field or general readers? What are their expectations for the writing?

Tailor your language: Use language that is appropriate for your audience. If your audience is not familiar with technical jargon, avoid using it in your writing. Instead, use language that is clear and easy to understand.

Address your audience's needs: Consider the questions or concerns that your audience might have and address them in your writing. This can help you to better connect with your readers and provide them with the information they are looking for.

Use examples: Use examples that are relevant to your audience to help illustrate your points. This can help your readers to better understand your message and how it applies to them.

Consider tone: The tone of your writing should be appropriate for your audience. Consider whether a formal or informal tone is appropriate for the audience, and make sure that the tone is consistent throughout the writing.

References:

  1. Editing Checklist | Writing Center GMU
  2. Self-Editing - Communication Program | Wharton UPenn